The sf6d is a measure for converting responses to the sf 36 or sf12 38 to a preferencebased qol score for economic evaluation. Evaluation of the eq5d5l tool showed that 97% n237 of all patients who responded to the question. Pdf deriving a mapping algorithm for converting sf36. For the eq5d and the multiple sclerosis impact scale8d, the best performing. Mapping the srs22r questionnaire onto the eq5d5l utility. For example, to map sf 36 to the eq5d, an estimation sample is used to estimate models regressing the eq5d on sf 36 variables. The switch from eq 5d 3l and eq 5d 5l could impact on the economic evaluation results, posing a challenge to policy makers and researchers who have been using eq 5d 3l to conduct costeffectiveness analysis. Sf12 the 12item shortform health survey sf12 is an instrument derived from the longer 36 item shortform sf 36,11 which was designed to measure general health functioning.
The new, fivelevel version of the eq 5d eq 5d 5l questionnaire has better psychometric properties than the standard threelevel version eq 5d 3l, including a reduced ceiling effect. The sf12 items measure physical or emotional limitations, physical functioning, pain, general health, vitality, social functioning, and mental health problems. Estimating the association between sf36 responses and eq. Article pdf available in health and quality of life outcomes 71. This study provides mapping algorithms for estimating the eq5d index from the sf36 profile using individual. Eq 5d 5l utility scores were regressed on demographics, cobb angle, curve types, treatment modalities, and five domains of the srs22r questionnaire. Deriving a mapping algorithm for converting sf36 scores to eq5d utility score in a. Headtohead comparison between the eq5d5l and the eq5d3l. Pdf background there is no research on mapping algorithms between eq5d. Individual data n 2211 were collected from three different studies and separated into derivation n 1660 and internal validation sets n 551. Deriving a mapping algorithm for converting sf 36 scores to eq5d utility score in a korean population article pdf available in health and quality of life outcomes 121. Japanese population norms for preferencebased measures. Position statement on use of the eq5d5l value set for. Mapping womac onto the eq5d5l utility index in patients.
When the guide was written, there was no value set for eq. Mapping to obtain eq5d utility values for use in nice. Assessment of outcome measures for costutility analysis in. Background the eq 5d, a generic health status questionnaire that is widely used in health economic evaluation, was recently expanded to the eq 5d 5l to address criticisms of unresponsiveness and ceiling effect. Research article mapping the srs22r questionnaire onto the eq5d5l utility score in patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis carlos king ho wong1. Comparison of eq5d, hui, and sf 36 derived societal health state values among spine patient outcomes research trial sport participants christine m. Deriving a mapping algorithm for converting sf36 scores to eq5d. Eligible participants were asked to complete a sociodemographic and clinical form, the eq5d3l, including the vas, sf 36 version 2, and eq5d5l without the vas as it is similar to the one from the eq5d3l. Eq5d3l is the nices preferred measure of hrqol in their technology appraisals nice, 20. This study is a head to head comparison to assess how expanding the number of levels from three eq 5d 3l to five in the new eq 5d 5l version has improved its distribution, discriminatory power, and validity in the general population. Currently, there are 3 studies focusing on mapping from factb to eq5d 16. Thus, there is a need to develop mapping algorithm with the publication of the new directly elicited eq 5d 5l utilities. The eq5d 5l creates a total of 3,125 unique health states 55. Generic health instruments like the euroqol 5dimension eq5d is important for the costutility analysis of health care interventions and calculation of qualityadjusted life years.
In this respect, the present study is well suited to a mapping approach because the dimensions of the eq 5d 3l and the eq 5d 5l are identical. Deriving an algorithm to convert the eight mean sf36 dimension. Accordingly, this paper makes two important contributions. Eligible participants were asked to complete a sociodemographic and clinical form, the eq5d3l, including the vas, sf 36 version 2, and eq 5d 5l without the vas as it. For example, to map sf36 to the eq5d, an estimation sample is used to estimate models regressing the eq5d on sf36 variables.
This study was conducted in 2012 with 116 patients that took the eq 5d 5l and a number of patientreported outcome instruments in a university orthopaedic clinic. Changes included in this update of the eq 5d 5l user guide updates have been made to nearly all sections of the user guide, including. To compare a range of statistical models to enable the estimation of eq5d3l utilities from responses to the parkinsons disease questionnaire 39 pdq. The eq5d3l and eq5d5l descriptive systems were coadministered to respondents with conditions of varying severity to ensure a broad range of levels of health. Euroqol5 dimension questionnaire rehabmeasures database. Mapping function from factb to eq5d5 l using multiple modelling. Alastair gray1, philip clarke 1,2, oliver riveroarias1. Donna rowena, john braziera and jennifer robertsb a health economics and decision science, university of sheffield, regent court, 30regent street, sheffield, s1 4da, uk. Aims to describe the validity, responsiveness and minimum important difference of the eq 5d 5l in copd. Apr 26, 2017 this was achieved by mapping eq 5d 3l and eq 5d 5l ratings through cross tabulations by each dimension level. The eq5d3l and eq 5d5l descriptive systems were coadministered to respondents with conditions of varying severity to ensure a broad range of levels of health. To develop algorithms mapping the kidney disease quality of life 36 item short form survey kdqol 36 onto the 3level eq5d questionnaire eq5d3l and the 5level eq5d questionnaire eq5d5l for patients with endstage renal disease requiring dialysis. Deriving a mapping algorithm for converting sf36 scores to.
Mapping the sf12 to the euroqol eq5d index in a national us sample. They showed an acceptable fit and precision and could be very useful for clinicians and researchers when costeffectiveness studies are needed and generic preferencebased healthrelated quality of life instruments to derive utilities are not available. The objective of the study was to compare the euroqol eq5d euroqol and shortform 36 sf 36 health questionnaires in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome cfs. Research open access deriving a mapping algorithm for. The aim of this study was to derive a predictive model for converting the sf 36 health profile to the eq5d index using data from several studies. Currently, there are few existing population norms for the eq 5d 5l. Pdf mapping the kidney disease quality of life 36item. Purpose the purpose of this study was to measure the population norms for the japanese versions of preferencebased measures eq 5d 3l, eq 5d 5l, and sf 6d.
How can i calculate quality of life utility values from sf. Each dimension is described by 3 possible levels of problems. How can i calculate quality of life utility values from sf 36 scores or sss score. Eq 5d 5l appears to have better measurement properties than eq 5d 3l. Mean rank, equipercentile and regression mapping of world. To our knowledge, these are the first functions mapping the womac onto the eq 5d 5l in patients with hip or knee oa. Mapping the kidney disease quality of life 36item short form. Euroqol researchers have suggested an interim scoring system of mappingor crosswalking the eq5d5l to the eq5d3l value sets. Mapping to obtain eq5d utility values for use in nice health. One of the major limitations of mapping items from one measure to another to estimate a utilitybased summary score is the difference in content coverage. The 12item shortform health survey sf12 is an instrument derived from the longer 36 item shortform sf 36, 11 which was designed to measure general health functioning. This study aimed to compare the utilitybased eq 5d 5l index scores derived from the two approaches as a means to validating the mapping function developed by van hout et al for the eq 5d 5l.
Comparing the uk eq5d3l and the english eq5d5l value sets english eq5d3l questionnaire ppt eq5d, hui and sf 36 powerpoint presentation, free download. Using above official euroqol crosswalk probabilities, an interim value set for the sri lankan eq 5d 5l health states were generated based upon the sri lankan eq 5d 3l value set which was estimated using time tradeoff method. Mapping the diseasespecific lupusqol to the sf6d mijnbsl. The sf 36 3941 is the most widely used measure for assessing health states in the world. Therefore in practical applications the published results and algorithms are used and it is not feasible to reestimate the model.
Concerns about the lack of sensitivity of eq5d3l and the presence of ceiling effects lead to the development of a new instrument, eq5d5l. Full text realworld utilities and healthrelated quality. Research open access deriving a mapping algorithm for converting sf 36 scores to eq5d utility score in a korean population seonha kim1, seonok kim2, sangil lee3 and minwoo jo3 abstract background. Cdisc standards for questionnaires include controlled terminology for test codes, test names, standard timing values, standard results for database values and an annotated crf with the sdtm qs domain variable names. Ordinary least squares regression was undertaken to develop mapping models, which the validity and robustness were assessed by using the 10fold crossvalidation procedure. The use of eq 5d 5l in asian hta systems ataru igarashi. Predicting the eq5d3l preference index from the sf12. Mark an x on the scale to indicate how your health is today. Mapping from the parkinsons disease questionnaire pdq39. Testing alternative regression models to predict utilities. Eq5d5l index value, is not explored in this study because thealgorithms for calculating eq5d5l index scores have yet to be developed for canada. Psychometric validation of the euroqol 5dimension eq5d. Mapping sri lankan eq5d3l to eq5d5l value sets value in.
However, the applicability of the eq5d health measure in chinese patients with spa is currently. Health economics and decision science discussion paper series no. There is no research on mapping algorithms between eq5d and sf 36 in korea. Introduction this guide has been developed in order to give users basic information on how to use the eq 5d 5l version. Throughout the article, mapping to the eq5d is provided as an example. Comparison of eq5d, hui, and sf36derived societal health. Health related quality of life aspects not captured by eq5d. Assessment of outcome measures for costutility analysis in depression. The model is used as a prediction equation to predict the eq5d in the clinical trial or other study of interest that contains sf 36 data, and these predicted values can then be used in an economic model. Jan 30, 2019 spondyloarthritis spa has a significant impact on patients quality of life due to functional impairments. Two prior studies from singapore performed mapping functions from factb to eq5d5l among breast cancer patients, and applied the utilityscoring systems, which were derived from data of british and japanese patients 17, 18. Do eq5d3l and eq5d5l capture the same changes in quality of life comparison of the eq5d and sf12 in a general population survey full text comparison of eq5d5l health state utilities using. We take this approach because mapping is used in economic evaluations to estimate the eq5d using the sf 36 or sf 12 when this is the only health status measure that has been included in the trial.
Mapping the kidney disease quality of life 36 item short form survey kdqol 36 to the eq5d3l and the eq 5d5l in patients undergoing dialysis. To derive a mapping algorithm to predict sf 6d utility scores from the nonpreferencebased lupusqol and test the performance of the developed algorithm on a separate independent validation data set. Similarly, mapping studies between qlqc30 and the sf 6d are sparse 16. Regression analyses were conducted to predict eq 5d 5l index scores from the le cat, promis pf cat, depression cat, and pain cat. Sep 24, 2014 there is no research on mapping algorithms between eq5d and sf 36 in korea. The eq 5d has been frequently used in national health surveys. Topics includeadministering the instrument, setting up a database for data collected using eq 5d 5l as well. Mapping function from factb to eq5d5 l using multiple. Mapping to ordinal eq 5d responses in the first part of the analysis, regression analysis is used to explore the association between responses to the sf 36 again using either individual items or domain summary scores and responses to each eq 5d question. Our current guide to the methods of technology appraisal 20 states that data collected using the eq. Nov 27, 2012 applicable to a wide range of health conditions and treatments, the eq 5d health questionnaire provides a simple descriptive profile and a single index value for health status.
413 110 139 1498 22 636 1383 1027 1543 860 433 848 1268 1348 689 660 1361 72 1060 396 992 177 692 131 508 1243 1370 938 1464 660 1239